Bongino’s FBI Polygraph Scandal: What’s Really Happening?

A man in a suit speaking at a podium during a conference

A new co-deputy director structure at the FBI raises questions about Dan Bongino’s tenure amid rising tensions and internal controversies.

Story Highlights

Dan Bongino remains FBI Deputy Director, sharing the role with Andrew Bailey.
Controversies include polygraph waivers and alleged purges of career FBI staff.
Speculation grows over potential diminished confidence from the White House.
Bongino’s leadership continues amidst political and institutional pressures.

Unprecedented Leadership Dynamics at the FBI

In February 2025, President Trump appointed Dan Bongino as the Deputy Director of the FBI, sparking significant debate due to his lack of FBI experience and previous media roles. Bongino, known for his staunch conservative views, took office on March 17, 2025, under the leadership of Director Kash Patel. This appointment deviated from the traditional practice of selecting career FBI executives, raising concerns about the politicization of the Bureau’s leadership.

Despite these concerns, Bongino announced the reopening of several high-profile investigations, including the January 5, 2021 RNC/DNC pipe bombs case. However, his tenure has been marred by controversies such as polygraph waivers for himself and senior staff, and allegations of purges targeting career FBI officials. These actions have led to tensions with the Department of Justice and internal criticism, further complicating his leadership role.

Co-Deputy Director Structure Introduced

In August 2025, the Department of Justice announced a new co-deputy director structure at the FBI, appointing Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey alongside Bongino. This move was seen by many as a potential sign of diminished confidence in Bongino’s ability to lead alone, but it also reinforced that he remains a key player within the agency. The introduction of Bailey as a co-deputy prompted speculation about internal dynamics and potential power shifts within the Bureau.

The ProPublica investigation highlighted the implications of this structural change, suggesting it might be a mechanism to counterbalance Bongino’s influence. Despite this, Bongino’s tenure continues to be defined by his alignment with President Trump’s administration and his efforts to implement a hardline, pro-Trump agenda within the FBI.

Implications for the Future of the FBI

The current leadership arrangement at the FBI raises significant questions about its future operations and integrity. With ongoing speculations and controversies, the co-deputy director structure could lead to overlapping authorities and slower decision-making processes. Moreover, the politicization of investigations under a partisan leadership invites doubts about selective enforcement and retribution.

As Bongino navigates the complexities of his role amid political and institutional pressures, the FBI faces challenges in maintaining its operational continuity and morale among agents. The broader implications of his leadership, including potential legal and constitutional questions, will continue to shape the narrative around the FBI’s role in upholding justice and national security.